Eat Like a Local on Treasure Island
One of the best parts of staying at The Molloy is that you can walk to some of the island’s favorite restaurants. Treasure Island’s food scene is casual, flavorful, and always close to the beach. Whether you want a laid-back lunch with Gulf views or a romantic seafood dinner, you’ll find it just steps away.
Here are ten great restaurants within walking distance of The Molloy that capture the island’s easygoing charm.
1. Caddy’s Treasure Island
Distance: 5-minute walk
Vibe: Beachfront bar and grill
Caddy’s is an island institution. Pull up a chair right in the sand, order fish tacos or a grouper sandwich, and enjoy live music most afternoons. It’s family-friendly during the day and turns lively as the sun sets.
Note: The main structure at Cadddy’s was damaged in Hurricane Helene. While under construction they have set up large temporary structure to continue operations.
Local tip: Go early for breakfast on weekends when the beach is still quiet and the mimosas are flowing.
2. Sloppy Joe’s on the Beach
Distance: 8-minute walk north
Vibe: Classic beach bar with a view
This lively spot has indoor and outdoor seating facing the Gulf. Burgers, seafood baskets, and cold drinks make it an easy choice after a day in the sun.
Local tip: Sit on the patio at sunset. The view rivals any restaurant in the area.
3. Britt’s Pizza
Distance: 10-minute walk east on Gulf Boulevard
Vibe: Late-night pizza joint
Britt’s serves thin-crust pizza and calzones baked in a stone oven. Grab a slice to go or eat outside under the string lights.
Local tip: Try the white pizza with fresh spinach, it’s a local favorite.
4. The Floridian
Distance: 7-minute walk
Vibe: Laid-back Cuban café
Known for its authentic Cuban sandwiches and roast pork platters, The Floridian is perfect for a quick, hearty lunch.
Local tip: Order the “Floridian Special” with extra pickles and a side of plantains.
5. Foxy’s Café
Distance: 6-minute walk inland
Vibe: Classic diner breakfast
Foxy’s has been serving locals for decades. You’ll find pancakes, omelets, and fresh coffee in a relaxed setting that feels like old Florida.
Local tip: Arrive before 9 a.m. to beat the breakfast rush.
6. Middle Grounds Grill
Distance: 12-minute walk or a short drive
Vibe: Upscale seafood and steakhouse
Middle Grounds Grill is ideal for date night or a special occasion. Expect fresh catch, expertly prepared steaks, and an extensive wine list.
Local tip: Ask for the daily fish special. It’s usually caught that morning.
7. VIP Mexican American Cuisine
Distance: 9-minute walk
Vibe: Festive Tex-Mex hangout
This colorful local favorite is famous for its strong margaritas and heaping nacho plates. Portions are generous, and the staff treats everyone like regulars.
Local tip: The VIP Burrito is big enough to share.
8. Ricky T’s Bar & Grill
Distance: 7-minute walk
Vibe: Casual sports bar with live music
Ricky T’s draws a friendly crowd for lunch, happy hour, and late-night music. It’s one of the few spots where you can catch a game and listen to a band in the same night.
Local tip: Stop by on Sunday mornings for their build-your-own Bloody Mary bar.
9. Sea Dog Brewing Co.
Distance: 11-minute walk north
Vibe: Brewpub with waterfront views
A relaxed spot for craft beer lovers, Sea Dog offers house-brewed ales, burgers, and seafood with a great view of the intracoastal waterway.
Local tip: Try the blueberry ale, it pairs perfectly with the fish and chips.
10. Shrimpys Blues Bistro
Distance: 10-minute walk toward John’s Pass**
Vibe: Cajun seafood and live jazz
Shrimpys serves New Orleans-inspired dishes with a Florida twist. The outdoor patio overlooks the water, and the music adds a lively touch to dinner.
Local tip: The shrimp and grits are a must-try, and the bread pudding is the perfect ending.
Wrap-Up: Eat, Stroll, Repeat
Treasure Island’s dining scene is relaxed, diverse, and right at your doorstep when you stay at The Molloy. From morning coffee runs to sunset cocktails, every meal can be a short walk away.
Plan your stay at The Molloy and enjoy the simple pleasure of walking from your room straight to some of the best restaurants on Florida’s Gulf Coast.
